I found this in some old files:
• C & C Car and Jeep Rental 340-693-8164

• Conrad Sutton Car Rental 340-776-6479 Fax 340-693-8099

• Cool Breeze Car Rental 340-776-6588

• Courtesy Car & Jeep Rental 340-776-6650

• Delbert Hill's Jeep Rentals 340-776-6637

• Hospitality Car and Jeep Rentals 340-693-9160

• L&L Jeep Rental Inc, 340-776-1120 : [www.bookajeep.com]

• Lionel Jeep Rental 340-693-8764

• O'Connor Jeep Rental 340-776-6343

• Paris Car Rental 340-776-6171

• Penn’s 340-776-6530.

• St. John Car Rental, Inc. 340-776-6103 Fax (340) 776-6103

• Sun & Sand Car Rental 340-776-6374

• Sutton Conrad Car Rental 340-776-6479

• Varlack Car Rental 340-776-6412 fax: 340-693-8276

Our agency was right in Cruz Bay but I'm not sure which one