First off, thank you thank you for your responses! I really appreciate it. I am actually deciding between Harbour Island or Nicaragua (I know, kinda random, but theres a method to my madness).

I was hesitant about the Silver flight b/c it is a short jaunt with confirmed lodging required.

The MGA (actually Rivas choice) is amazing but the hotel is new and being very inconsistent in booking.

Thank you again!