Hi Overworked,

Did you check out my article that Migflanker directed you to? We really enjoyed Isla. Let me know if you have any questions.

It is a very small island. We stayed out from downtown. If I went back, I'd probably stay right in town where all the restaurants and shops are. It's a short walk to the most popular beach - Playa Norte. You can then easily see the rest of the island in a day with a fun scooter rental. We really enjoyed our boat ride to Contoy island.